A Review of Anne Enright’s Attention: Writing on Life, Art, and the World

“In 1993, when [Toni] Morrison won the Nobel Prize,” Anne Enright writes in Attention, “men (including one Nobel Prize winner), asked me, ‘Is she that good?’ As though I might know in some way they could not – I could read like a woman, perhaps.”

What does it mean, then, to read like a woman? If any writer were capable, it is Enright herself.

Attention: Writing on Life, Art, and the World is a collection of Enright’s critical works, many pulled from the London Review of Books and the New York Review of Books or adapted from lectures. It’s about being a female writer, and it’s about being an Irish writer, embodying and challenging both labels in equal measure.

“Men and women are read differently, even when they write the same thing,” she argues. One might say the same about the Irish and non-Irish. The collection’s first movement, Voices, examines what we allow writers to mine for material—gender, violence, sexism, moral failure, ethnicity, religion, places that belong to us, and places that don’t. Bodies examines what women, women writers especially, are afforded and denied. The third, Time, finally reveals Enright the person—a woman, shaped by place, yet wanting to be free of its physical limitations.

Front to back, the collection is imbalanced. The second essay, “I Stab and I Stab,” examines Helen Garner’s writings about her relationship with the author Murray Bail, who is controlling and dismissive and chauvinistic and also very frail, asking her “not to write about him in her diaries.” It is a painful recounting of Garner’s’s diaries, blow by blow, to the point of tedium—a strange starter considering the strength of the other pieces, though the arrangement of Attention may mean to introduce us to Enright slowly. It would be better to start that way—her memoiristic voice is clever and funny, though reserved. One is left with the sense that much more is going on off the page.

Enright does not resist male writers. In “The High Irish Style,” on the life and work of John McGahern, a deeply flawed man who shares much in common with his female contemporaries: physically brutalized and yet condemned for mining his experience for material. What can and cannot be fictionalized is a repeated question. Enright challenges Alice Munro, who ostensibly mined the sexual abuse of her daughter Andrea at the hands of Munro’s own husband to write short stories while at the same time blaming and punishing Andrea for what happened. Even with this knowledge, Enright writes that she “cannot take back my great love for her work.”

Younger readers may be bored by the lack of original feminist arguments in the book and assume Enright walks a step, or more, behind questions of modern sexual liberation, like, for instance, whether a woman can still be a feminist and desire to take a submissive role in a sexual encounter with a man—a matter long settled by the Third Wave: feminism is about choice.

Yet Enright was born in Ireland in 1962, and readers in other parts of the west may not understand with what breakneck speed the country has developed and how quickly—though not completely—it has thrown off the mantle of the Catholic church. Divorce was made legal in only 1996, abortion in 2018, and the last Magdalene Laundry was closed in 1996. We’ve had the internet for longer. But as The Powers That Be seem rabid to control women in the 21st century, Enright’s words are ever more foresighted. Though many women in the US today were born into the world of Roe v. Wade, we no longer live in it. Can one write about women without writing about the body? It is Enright’s vehicle into the feminist debate.

Attention also asks: What does it mean to be an Irish writer? In England, Enright is regarded as “amusing, in an Irish sort of way.” And of the author Edna O’Brien, she laments that “Americans especially saw her as quintessentially Irish, rarely failing to mention the green eyes, the auburn hair, the mellifluous fluency.” Others are called “endearing” or have stereotypes “foisted” upon them “in the name of Ireland.” Enright’s complaints about Irish stereotypes aren’t helped by her compulsion to write about James Joyce, not only in the “Ulysses: An Introduction,” written for the Vintage UK centenary release of the book, but throughout the collection.

There are so many great Irish writers, and Enright regrets that more aren’t broadly known. And indeed she is right. Most readers outside of Ireland today won’t be familiar with Maeve Brennan, Edna O’Brien, or John McGahern—all of whom are dead. But the twenty-first century is the “golden age of Irish fiction,” reads the introduction to the Everyman’s Library Pocket Classics collection of Irish Stories, also out in 2026, in which Enright is anthologized alongside her literary heroes, including Brennan and O’Brien. And indeed, most readers in the US could name at least three Irish writers working today—including women like Claire Keegan, Sally Rooney, Maggie O’Farrell, and Enright herself. Given the literary genius that naturally springs eternal from that land, we could use, and will no doubt see, even more.

With her reflections on womanhood and on Irishness, Enright marks the passage of time, reminding us of a very recent history in which women were intentionally overlooked, abused, and thwarted, while ignoring the fact that female Irish writers, in many ways—rule literature today. For her predecessors, the death of the person also marked the death of the writer in literary canon. Her warning may be: Let us not make the same mistake.

It isn’t until the third movement of the collection, called Time, that we meet Enright as a writer, and not just an Irish writer, though the references to Joyce continue. Even in “Dublin Made Me,” we meet a woman shaped by place—a fact that would still be true if it were Dubai or Dresden. Indeed, Enright the writer and Enright the woman are also made in chance encounters in Canada and Venice and in a cycling holiday across Italy. Perhaps it is Irish, then, to be so shaped by a place. Perhaps it is female to be so shaped by a body. “You are here,” she writes. “Though it is hard to know what the word contains, or what a sense of hereness is – the glorious feeling of being in one place and no other.”

***

Avatar photo
Emily McCrary

Emily McCrary is a writer and journalist living in Richmond, Virginia. Her work has appeared in Oxford American, LitHub, Deep South, the BBC, and the Economist, among others. Her work has been syndicated in Burnaway, Longreads, and Reader’s Digest, and translated into Italian for Internazionale.